Analysis

Nigeria’s Fuel Import Debate Exposes Regulatory Gaps as Domestic Refining Expands

-Felix Douglas

Legal uncertainty over petroleum product imports, domestic refining capacity and consumer protection is emerging as a major challenge for Nigeria’s downstream petroleum industry, with stakeholders calling for clearer regulatory guidelines to balance competition, investment and national energy security.

Nigeria’s transition from a petroleum product import-dependent market towards increased domestic refining has exposed significant legal and regulatory questions over the continued issuance of import licences, the protection of domestic refiners and the need to sustain competition in the downstream petroleum sector.

Industry stakeholders have warned that although domestic refining capacity has expanded considerably, the absence of clear rules governing when petroleum product imports should be permitted continues to create uncertainty for refiners, marketers, regulators and consumers.

The issues were highlighted by Dr Emeka Akabogu (SAN) during his presentation at the Centre for Petroleum Information (CPI) Webinar Edition: Oil & Gas Law Forum where he examined the legal framework governing petroleum product importation under the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA), ongoing disputes between domestic refiners, importers and implications for consumers.

Dr. Akabogu stressed further that Nigeria’s changing position in the petroleum market presented a paradox: despite increased domestic refining and the country’s emergence as a net exporter of fuel in 2026, petroleum product imports remain part of the domestic supply mix.

According to the legal expert, the Nigerian Midstream and Downstream Petroleum Regulatory Authority (NMDPRA), issued import licences for approximately 830,000 metric tonnes of petroleum products for the fourth quarter of 2026, raising questions about the circumstances under which imports should be allowed when substantial domestic refining capacity exists.

Dr. Akabogu questioned who should determine the necessity for imports, the conditions under which import licences could lawfully be issued and how consumers should be protected when competing supply arrangements do not necessarily translate into lower prices at the pump.

Import Expenditure and the Impact of Domestic Refining

Presenting historical import expenditure figures, Dr. Akabogu explained that Nigeria had committed substantial financial resources to importing petroleum products over the years, placing pressure on the country’s foreign exchange market.

He disclosed that average annual expenditure on petroleum product imports between 2022 and 2023 stood at approximately N7.5 trillion, rising sharply to N15.4 trillion in 2024 before declining to N8.9 trillion in 2025.

He attributed the reduction largely to the commencement and subsequent expansion of operations at the Dangote Petroleum Refinery, which began production in 2024 and significantly increased output in 2025.

According to him, increased domestic production has helped retain foreign exchange that would otherwise have been spent on importing refined petroleum products.

Dr. Akabogu argued that the relationship between domestic refinery output and movements in the foreign exchange market demonstrated the wider economic importance of strengthening local refining capacity.

However, he observed that imports had not disappeared from the domestic supply chain, with imported and locally refined products continuing to contribute varying proportions of market supply between November 2025 and September 2026.

He explained that domestic refining had assumed a stronger position in the supply mix from January 2026, although imported products remained part of the market.

Disagreement over Import Licences

The presentation identified Section 317 of the PIA, which provides for a backward integration policy, as central to the disagreement between domestic refiners and petroleum product importers.

Dr. Akabogu explained that domestic refiners had relied on the provision to argue that companies with significant investments in local refining should receive preferential treatment in the petroleum market.

The position advanced by the refiner, he said, was that petroleum product imports should only be permitted where domestic production cannot adequately meet national demand.

The argument also draws on Section 319 of the PIA, with the refiner maintaining that import licences issued in the absence of genuine domestic supply shortfalls fall outside the regulator’s statutory powers.

He disclosed that the dispute had resulted in multiple legal actions, with the refiner instituting as many as four cases in different courts since 2024.

In one of the earlier cases, the refiner challenged NMDPRA and major importers, including the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPC), seeking declarations that the issuance of import licences violated the PIA.

It also sought the withdrawal of existing licences, an order restraining further issuance of licences and damages against the regulator and importers.

The regulator, however, maintained in its response that Nigeria still had petroleum product supply shortfalls and that import licences were necessary to safeguard national energy security.

The case was subsequently discontinued by the refiner after the parties had joined issues.

Dr. Akabogu further disclosed that another action was instituted in 2026 against the Attorney-General of the Federation, challenging the legality of petroleum product imports and seeking to restrain further issuance or renewal of import licences.

He noted that NNPC, which was involved in the proceedings, maintained that the PIA did not prohibit imports and argued that the domestic refinery’s pricing was relatively high and subject to fluctuations.

He explained that other subsequent cases had also been instituted, although he declined to discuss their substantive issues because some remained active before the courts.

Importers Defend Competition and Market Access

On the other side of the dispute, petroleum product importers have argued that their investments in the downstream market must also be protected.

According to Dr. Akabogu, importers maintain that they have committed substantial resources to developing petroleum supply infrastructure, including jetties and other facilities required to participate in the market.

They contend that domestic refining should not result in the exclusion of existing market participants or create a situation where one company exercises excessive control over national petroleum product supply.

He said importers had consequently placed emphasis on competition, investment protection and national energy security, arguing that no single operator should be allowed to determine the country’s petroleum supply circumstances.

Dr. Akabogu identified the case instituted by Matrix Energy against NMDPRA as particularly significant because, unlike some of the refiner’s actions, it had received a judgment on the merits.

He explained that the case raised questions about the regulator’s responsibility to promote competition under the PIA and the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act (FCCPA), as well as whether the PIA prohibited petroleum product imports.

According to his account, the court ruled in favour of the importers, holding that the regulatory framework, when the PIA is considered alongside competition legislation, requires the promotion of competition in the downstream market.

He said the court also held that the PIA did not prohibit petroleum product imports and directed that import licences should continue to be issued, provided applicants satisfied the applicable regulatory requirements and until market circumstances changed.

Need for clarity in the PIA

Beyond the ongoing litigation, Dr. Akabogu also identified the interpretation and implementation of the PIA’s backward integration provisions as a major regulatory concern.

He explained that Section 317 gives the regulator discretionary powers to apply a backward integration policy aimed at supporting domestic investments and ensuring that local refining capacity is optimised.

The oil and gas legal expert called for the development of specific guidelines establishing the conditions under which backward integration should apply, the advantages available to domestic refiners and how such a framework should coexist with competition and market access.

He also questioned the absence of a clearly established procedure for determining petroleum product supply shortfalls.

According to him, determining whether a shortfall exists requires an assessment of actual refinery production, available supply, operational capacity and national consumption requirements.

He also argued that installed refining capacity should not automatically be interpreted as sufficient supply, since the ability to produce petroleum products does not necessarily mean that the required volumes are consistently available to the domestic market.

Dr. Akabogu highlighted disagreements surrounding the regulatory status of certain refining operations, including arguments concerning the applicability of Nigerian petroleum regulations to facilities located within export processing or free trade zones.

He further drew attention to the domestic crude supply obligation under the PIA, noting that effective implementation requires coordination between the upstream and downstream petroleum regulators.

He said crude allocation to domestic refineries must operate within a transparent regulatory framework that ensures adequate feedstock supply and supports the country’s refining ambitions.

Dr. Akabogu identified NMDPRA’s responsibility as threefold: promoting a competitive downstream petroleum market, supporting domestic refining and protecting consumer interests.

He disclosed that the regulator had encouraged refiners and petroleum marketers to develop a common framework capable of addressing their disagreements and improving market operations.

He warned that the prolonged disagreements between refiners and marketers had created market practices that were not necessarily consistent with the competitive environment Nigeria seeks to establish.

Presenting figures on domestic supply and refining requirements, Akabogu said the regulator’s benchmark for national petroleum product demand stood at approximately 50 million litres daily, while the country’s current refining capacity was estimated at between 35 million and 41 million litres daily.

He said the figures indicated a potential supply gap, although the domestic refiner maintained that it could meet the country’s entire requirements if import licences were discontinued.

He stressed that the distinction between installed capacity and actual production remained central to determining whether imports were necessary.

According to him, the regulator must establish a transparent methodology for assessing domestic supply, identifying shortfalls and determining when import licences can legitimately be issued.

He expressed optimism that clearer guidelines could emerge before the end of 2026 as discussions between refiners, marketers and the regulator continued.

Dr. Akabogu said the ultimate consideration in resolving the importation dispute should be the interests of petroleum consumers.

The argument is that consumers should not be left to bear the consequences of regulatory uncertainty, commercial disagreements or market arrangements that fail to deliver competitive pricing.

Consumer protection should not depend on the outcome of any single court case but on transparent, published and auditable rules governing petroleum product imports and domestic distribution.

Such rules would provide certainty for refiners and marketers while ensuring that competition remains fair and consumers receive value.

In his concluding remarks, he stressed that Nigeria was increasingly refining products that it previously imported, making it necessary to adapt the country’s regulatory framework, which was originally developed around an import-dependent petroleum market.

He said the country must now establish clear rules that recognise the contributions of domestic refiners and importers while protecting national energy security and consumer interests.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comment here